Rule, you're probably right. What's she lying about though?
You've gotten several stories from her that are slightly inconsistent with one another. To be honest, she just sounds too selfish and cowardly to speak the unaltered truth to anyone. (I suppose this does not make her much different than most people though). Further, she's not really accepting responsibility: to one side she says "Scarlett MADE me..", and to the other she says "My mom and Matt MADE me..." In the end the choice (in both cases) is hers. Maybe talk to her about it? If you do though, come clean yourself in regards to reading her personal messages, otherwise you'll be a hypocrite
. I don't really want to have much of an influence on this situation, I just enjoy analyzing why people behave the way they do and predicting what they will do next.