Author Topic: Refute my objection?  (Read 5315 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Explicit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 717
  • Hail Bender!
    • View Profile
Refute my objection?
« on: October 07, 2006, 06:43:54 am »
I need help coming up with a refute to the objection.  In case you're wondering, it's for my essay in philosophy.  I'm to write an argument, object to one of the premises, and then refute the objection.  The problem is that I can't seem to find anything flawed or erroneous about it, so hopefully that's where you guys come in.

Quote
Someone objecting to never truly knowing if you were awake or dreaming would contend that on the contrary, you can truly know if you are awake or dreaming.  The reason being that we experience pain only when we are awake, and that as much as we perceive a dream to be reality, pain will never be something that a dream is capable of bringing into reality.
Quote
Like all things in life, pumping is just a primitive, degenerate form of bending.

Quote
Hey, I don't tell you how to tell me what to do, so don't tell me how to do what you tell me to do! ... Bender knows when to use finesse.

[13:41:45]<@Fapiko> Why is TehUser asking for wang pictures?
[13:42:03]<@TehUser> I wasn't asking for wang pictures, I was looking at them.
[13:47:40]<@TehUser> Mine's fairly short.

Offline rabbit

  • x86
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 8092
  • I speak for the entire clan (except Joe)
    • View Profile
Re: Refute my objection?
« Reply #1 on: October 07, 2006, 08:01:59 am »
But then if you are in such a weird place (like...Mars) and feel pain, does that mean that you are really on Mars?

Offline Explicit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 717
  • Hail Bender!
    • View Profile
Re: Refute my objection?
« Reply #2 on: October 07, 2006, 08:08:02 am »
But then if you are in such a weird place (like...Mars) and feel pain, does that mean that you are really on Mars?

Can you elaborate for me?
Quote
Like all things in life, pumping is just a primitive, degenerate form of bending.

Quote
Hey, I don't tell you how to tell me what to do, so don't tell me how to do what you tell me to do! ... Bender knows when to use finesse.

[13:41:45]<@Fapiko> Why is TehUser asking for wang pictures?
[13:42:03]<@TehUser> I wasn't asking for wang pictures, I was looking at them.
[13:47:40]<@TehUser> Mine's fairly short.

Offline Chavo

  • x86
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2219
  • no u
    • View Profile
    • Chavoland
Re: Refute my objection?
« Reply #3 on: October 07, 2006, 11:58:22 am »
You claim the premise that we cannot experience pain in dreams.  A premise with no grounds in this argument.  By the way, your wording in the first sentence is not very easy to read. 

Offline CrAz3D

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 10184
    • View Profile
Re: Refute my objection?
« Reply #4 on: October 07, 2006, 12:39:25 pm »
Could it be something along the lines of...

You currently know that there are 2 states, awake & asleep.  You've woken up from asleep & remember doing it.  You've never woken up from awake that you know of.

Offline Explicit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 717
  • Hail Bender!
    • View Profile
Re: Refute my objection?
« Reply #5 on: October 07, 2006, 01:15:28 pm »
You claim the premise that we cannot experience pain in dreams. A premise with no grounds in this argument. By the way, your wording in the first sentence is not very easy to read.

The premise is actually that we cannot truly know if we are awake or dreaming.

The whole thing about pain and not being able to experience it in dreams is the objection, and I'm trying to find a point that refutes it that still maintains the above premise.

And I apologize about the wording.  I did change that last night in my paper... rather, earlier this morning because I pulled an all-nighter, but I forgot to update it here.  You still get what I mean though, right?  :P
« Last Edit: October 07, 2006, 01:32:14 pm by Explicit[nK] »
Quote
Like all things in life, pumping is just a primitive, degenerate form of bending.

Quote
Hey, I don't tell you how to tell me what to do, so don't tell me how to do what you tell me to do! ... Bender knows when to use finesse.

[13:41:45]<@Fapiko> Why is TehUser asking for wang pictures?
[13:42:03]<@TehUser> I wasn't asking for wang pictures, I was looking at them.
[13:47:40]<@TehUser> Mine's fairly short.

Offline Explicit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 717
  • Hail Bender!
    • View Profile
Re: Refute my objection?
« Reply #6 on: October 07, 2006, 01:30:04 pm »
Could it be something along the lines of...

You currently know that there are 2 states, awake & asleep. You've woken up from asleep & remember doing it. You've never woken up from awake that you know of.

From the way I'm interpreting that, it still doesn't address how pain is experienced only when you're awake and never when you're dreaming.

What I have of it so far:
I wake up from dreaming -- pain does not exist.
I have never woke up from awake -- I can't be certain if pain exists.

Unless, forgive my misinterpretation if it's erroneous, you are getting at the point that the pain we perceive to experience in the reality of being awake doesn't exist, like how it doesn't exist when we are dreaming.  In other words, you're implying that there is another state of awakening above what we believe to be awake where the realm of pain actually exists?

Am I getting that right?

Edit: If that were the case, then how is it that we are able to distinguish between pain from no pain (awake vs dreaming)?  Wouldn't we still believe that pain exists as an actual thing in being awake?  Put another way, how do we know that in dreams, we feel no pain, but in being awake, we do feel pain?
« Last Edit: October 07, 2006, 01:49:47 pm by Explicit[nK] »
Quote
Like all things in life, pumping is just a primitive, degenerate form of bending.

Quote
Hey, I don't tell you how to tell me what to do, so don't tell me how to do what you tell me to do! ... Bender knows when to use finesse.

[13:41:45]<@Fapiko> Why is TehUser asking for wang pictures?
[13:42:03]<@TehUser> I wasn't asking for wang pictures, I was looking at them.
[13:47:40]<@TehUser> Mine's fairly short.

Offline rabbit

  • x86
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 8092
  • I speak for the entire clan (except Joe)
    • View Profile
Re: Refute my objection?
« Reply #7 on: October 07, 2006, 03:29:18 pm »
How do we know pain exists only when awake?  Maybe it's completely opposite?

Offline Explicit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 717
  • Hail Bender!
    • View Profile
Re: Refute my objection?
« Reply #8 on: October 07, 2006, 03:45:24 pm »
How do we know pain exists only when awake? Maybe it's completely opposite?

Well, I don't see any in-between for when you're awake or dreaming.  It's either you're awake, you're dreaming, or you just are, the last one being that you exist but don't think or perceive anything at all.  But if that were the case, the argument would branch off into how you could exist without being a thinking thing (something external to the mind), which is still what philosophers are still trying to figure out today.  That would not be possible since we are all (us people that is) thinking things (referring to the cogito).

By opposite, do you mean that we experience pain when we're dreaming and we don't experience it when we're awake?  How would that logically follow?
« Last Edit: October 07, 2006, 03:48:17 pm by Explicit[nK] »
Quote
Like all things in life, pumping is just a primitive, degenerate form of bending.

Quote
Hey, I don't tell you how to tell me what to do, so don't tell me how to do what you tell me to do! ... Bender knows when to use finesse.

[13:41:45]<@Fapiko> Why is TehUser asking for wang pictures?
[13:42:03]<@TehUser> I wasn't asking for wang pictures, I was looking at them.
[13:47:40]<@TehUser> Mine's fairly short.

Offline rabbit

  • x86
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 8092
  • I speak for the entire clan (except Joe)
    • View Profile
Re: Refute my objection?
« Reply #9 on: October 07, 2006, 05:31:32 pm »
Maybe we think we're awake when we're dreaming?  There's an episode of Stargate SG-1 (season 9, IIRC) where one of the characters gets his brain screwed with.  He always thinks he's awake because when he goes to sleep in one state he wakes up in the other.  Both seem completely real to him.  It was a fun episode :)

Offline Explicit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 717
  • Hail Bender!
    • View Profile
Re: Refute my objection?
« Reply #10 on: October 08, 2006, 12:23:37 am »
Maybe we think we're awake when we're dreaming? There's an episode of Stargate SG-1 (season 9, IIRC) where one of the characters gets his brain screwed with. He always thinks he's awake because when he goes to sleep in one state he wakes up in the other. Both seem completely real to him. It was a fun episode :)

Can you find a link to the episode for me?  It sounds really trippy.  :P
Quote
Like all things in life, pumping is just a primitive, degenerate form of bending.

Quote
Hey, I don't tell you how to tell me what to do, so don't tell me how to do what you tell me to do! ... Bender knows when to use finesse.

[13:41:45]<@Fapiko> Why is TehUser asking for wang pictures?
[13:42:03]<@TehUser> I wasn't asking for wang pictures, I was looking at them.
[13:47:40]<@TehUser> Mine's fairly short.

Offline Explicit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 717
  • Hail Bender!
    • View Profile
Re: Refute my objection?
« Reply #11 on: October 08, 2006, 04:28:10 am »
Okay, thus far, I've come up with this refute to the objection:

Quote
My response to this is that pain is a conception of the mind whether it is in a dream, or when you are awake.  Whenever we talk about pain as an experience, we talk about them as if they are an object of some sort of inner perception, the implication being introspection.  If that be the case, it would suggest that pain is a purely subjective experience rather than an objective one.  After all, the experiences we perceive are all in the mind.


Does anyone see anything invalid or unsound about this?
Quote
Like all things in life, pumping is just a primitive, degenerate form of bending.

Quote
Hey, I don't tell you how to tell me what to do, so don't tell me how to do what you tell me to do! ... Bender knows when to use finesse.

[13:41:45]<@Fapiko> Why is TehUser asking for wang pictures?
[13:42:03]<@TehUser> I wasn't asking for wang pictures, I was looking at them.
[13:47:40]<@TehUser> Mine's fairly short.

Offline rabbit

  • x86
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 8092
  • I speak for the entire clan (except Joe)
    • View Profile
Re: Refute my objection?
« Reply #12 on: October 08, 2006, 07:57:45 am »
'The Changeling'
EPISODE NUMBER - 619
ORIGINAL U.S. AIR DATE - 02.28.03
SYNDICATION AIR DATE - 04.26.04
WRITTEN BY - Christopher Judge, Brad Wright
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Changeling_(Stargate_SG-1)