61
General Discussion / Re: Dune
« on: August 24, 2011, 04:03:53 pm »How did you manage to persevere through book 3? Even with the cool prospect of Alia being taken over by the Barron, the series turned awful. The characters became far more conniving, but it seemed contrived. The plot was dull. Leto II didn't come off with the charm that Paul did.Haha! Yeah, like I said, Children of Dune was definitely one of the harder ones for me to read. Definitely avoid God Emperor of Dune if you hated Children of Dune. While Leto II's story is somewhat interesting, Frank Herbert's back and forth between the first and third-person perspectives grows old quickly, and you can't help but feel Leto II set it all up from the start. Brian Herbert and Kevin Anderson did a decent job with Hunters of Dune, Sandworms of Dune, and Paul of Dune. Hunters of Dune and Sandworms of Dune give the series a decent ending after the cliffhanger in Chapterhouse Dune.
Do you recommend Brian Herbert/Kevin Anderson's novels on Dune? I avoided them on the basis that derivative works, even based on the author's notes, are terrible.